Wednesday, November 12, 2014

What role does the artist play in shaping the meaning of the work?

Be they painter, composer, or writer, the artist is without a doubt the source of the work of art, at least in so much as it is a physical thing or has a physical manifestation. However, the artist does not give the meaning of the work of art, because this is not the nature of meaning. Meaning, whether in a linguistic or other semiological environment, is determined as a relation of the symbols to one another in a broader social context, and these symbols are not rigidly defined within their social context. As such, the person attending to the symbols determines the limits or overlapping of the symbols based on their own personal experience. The meaning is created through its reception in a viewer, not in its construction by the artist.
            Carroll makes an appeal to H.P. Grice’s theory of language in order to show that the artwork, particularly a literary work, has a determinate meaning. Grice says that a statement means p when A says something to B in order to make B believe that p by saying that something. What is important here is that the nature of everyday communication is not one-sided. The communicator A tries to express p, but this does not automatically mean that B will understand A’s utterance by how it is presented. When this is applied to a work of art, this becomes more problematic in that A, taking the form of the artwork, cannot provide feedback to B if B does not take away the ‘proper’ meaning. Carroll seeks to make literary works into conversational pieces, but he does not recognize that their status as works of art makes them different. In purely conversational speech, language is used as a piece of equipment; in poetry or prose, language is used for some effect beyond that of normal speech, hence its recognition as artwork. Thus, the artwork’s communication, by its ambiguous and opaque nature beyond mere equipmentality, opens up a wide range of possible meanings to be taken away from a single string of symbols, and the artwork cannot provide the feedback to ‘correct’ any interpretation.
            The author then might be able to come in and save the artwork from a seemingly anarchic multiplicity of meanings. The author is after all the one who made the thing to be interpreted. However, the author did not make the symbolic system into which the artwork is thrust, nor does she condition any particular viewer’s history of interaction with the words/images/colors/etc. Nehamas tries to thwart this by appeal to a postulated author, one who is not the author of the work but is the author in the work. This author, as an idealized entity, determines the meaning of the work by what he or she could have meant or what it could have meant to its particular audience at the time, and thus there is a sort of asymptotic ideal of what the work could mean. But this seems problematic as well. Given that nature of meaning in the Gricean terms requires the interpretation by a reader/viewer, the only people who could adequately meet the requirements of Nehamas’ ideal interpretation would be the hypothetical audience or author. Otherwise, all readers and viewers, even those who are very attentive to the historical context of the work, cannot help but bring to bear the own understandings or their own viewing of the work. As Devereaux noted in her work on the male gaze in art, there is no passive seeing, but only ways of seeing.
            Furthermore, Kant’s notion of artistic genius makes any authorial claim to meaning problematic. The Kantian genius is not a person, but more like a state of consciousness that some certain individuals have had that has allowed for the creation of works of art. This state, which produces artwork, is not explicable by the artists as to how and why they made it. So, if the method they have of producing what is artful about their creation is uncertain, and the meaning of the artwork is what makes it artful, then it follows that the artist is not in a position to explain what the meaning of the artwork is. Using the notion of genius, the artist makes the work, but then has to countersign that this work is in fact her production. In this countersigning, then, the artist comes to the same level of interpretive credibility as a well-informed critic.

The nature of art also is not one of a factical truth, as both Heidegger and Aristotle point out. What is there to be seen is not some one truth about a state of the world or one subjective opinion about that world, but rather an unveiling of Being as such. I think that Nehamas’ and Carroll’s insistence on some sort of authorial standard of meaning is a confusion brought about by the nature of language. Because the literary work makes use of tools used to communicate meaning for a different sort of purpose, there is a conflation of conversation usage with artistic truth which does not adequately account for the nature of the artwork. Art is semantically opaque and inexhaustible by its nature, and this comes out because it is made possible through the prescriptions of the artist, but rather through its perception by individual audience members.

Thursday, November 6, 2014

Lockhart's Lament

https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf

The first few pages is enough to give you the gist of the idea, as far as I'm concerned, but it's an interesting read if you have the time and inclination!

Sunday, November 2, 2014

4.0Reflection Paper (SL)

Nancun Yu
PR. Kyle Grady
PHIL 330: Aesthetics
29th, Oct. 2014

4.0Reflection Paper (SL)
Before we discuss whether an art work do communicate truth, the problem we must face is that what truth really is. I was struggling with my personally believe that there is truth in artworks when we entering this section. I think there are obviously truth values in the artworks. However, I cannot distinguish how “true” the Artistic truth is, in comparison in the broad sense of truth.
            In order to critique art we must choose a subject. In this case I would like to use artworks as the source. By Heidegger, The ultimate source of artworks is Art and Art is obviously present (exist) in artworks. Thus, if Art communicates the truth, the artworks must communicate the truth. Identically, many of the artworks contain the material of existing subjects. However, people cannot declare the truth value of artworks by identifying the existed physical subjects the artwork represents. It shifted back to the earlier question of whether artworks mainly represent. If we admitted that artwork represent another physical subject we correspondingly admitted that truth within artworks must be less realistic than the actual existed thing itself. Heidegger rejected that by separate artworks from the role of representation, he argues that measure the truth value based upon the represented subject hide the path to find real Artistic truth. It also granted by Kant, that Kant believes the pure aesthetic judgment should not involve anything other than the artwork itself as the subject.
            And again, the problem shifted back to the question of what is truth. From my personal experience, I think there had never been any standard of truth for examination. The truth can only defined by its time periods. And the idea of truth had also been changed throughout the history. The part reason of that, I think, is because human had never found the exact truth. In the past ages people practiced the thing they think are relevantly close to the truth. I.e., during the middle Ages, people believe that higher voice of music represents virtually, because they believe singing higher pitch make people closer to God. However, finding what does close to the subject not means that subject is the real truth. Furthermore, it is crucial to see that the technology improvement have been turning the previous unrealistic believe in true existed. The technology improvement had weaken the boundaries between illusory and real.
            Accordingly, the truth has such flexibility. And thus instead of saying the Artistic truth is not truth, I would rather call it another form of truth. By Heidegger, he argues the Artistic truth is actually more “real” than other form of truth. For Heidegger, artworks are where the truth originally floated. In order to understand what makes Heidegger means of Artistic truth people can trace back to his shoe store. He concluded that the Artistic truth is the truth create by being self-sufficient and being self-contained.
Again, it is likely that people struggling with the question how true the Artistic is. As we mentioned in class, the story told by Heidegger about the shoes in his essay is totally wrong. How can a falsehood story contained any truth? I would assume Heidegger will reply that the Artistic truth do not, and should not involve with the “truth” outside of artworks. In Heidegger’s opinion the artistic truth is independent. It is the process that creating the artistic truth within the artwork declare it into truth. The Artistic truth is meant to be self-sufficient.
            However, other than questioning the truth value of Artistic truth, there is another question need to be present: if the Artistic truth is the self-evaluated kind of truth, does that means the Artistic truth is a kind of subjective truth? It is identical that Heidegger was trying to not put Artistic truth into subjective truth. However, I feel it will make more sense if we agreed the concept of truth being subjective. Again, the question shifted back to the pure definition of truth. Majority people might think that truth are supposed to represent a universal concept, and thus, the truth should be objective instead of subjective. The key point here is how we define truth. Instead of defining truth by its quality of being “True, ” there is also a way to define truth as if it is convincible. That is the space lifted for subjective truth. As long as the subjective person decide to believe it, it is the relevant truth of that subjective being.

            Thus, the artwork does communicate truth, even know the Artistic truth is a less true version of truth in comparing with the other sense of “Truth”. 

Thursday, October 30, 2014

Reflection 4


                On first consideration, I was hesitant about how to answer this question. Before beginning this section of reading I thought for a long time on this question, and I was perplexed.  The first hurdle I had to overcome was the idea that artworks can communicate truth, but they do not necessarily communicate truth. This was an important question for me, because my idea was that the communication of truth as a necessity would automatically discount non-representational works of art and even the entire category of music as art. And then I was concerned about how strictly I was to understand this notion of truth. I began to work that fiction writing was at risk, because it is not based in the type of truth that is factual.

                Upon reading the philosophers in this section, I realized many of my worries were misguided. My worries about truth were taking truth to mean the strict true/false factual sense. In reading Aristotle, however, I found that art works could communicate truth. For Aristotle, this truth is not based in historical facts but general ideas. He notes that in art, specifically poetry, we get the universal truths. He also is forced to confront and acknowledge Plato who says that art is necessarily mimetic and therefore twice removed from the truth i.e. the forms. Aristotle confronts this by claiming that yes, artworks are mimetic, but they still hold universal truths. He goes on to explain the particulars of poetry and drama that make them so apt for communicating truth, however I found his one later claim about truth most intriguing. He explains that all of the elements of plot and tragedy, but they all amount to one thing. Our interest is in truth claims that are not 1) actually true, or 2) necessarily true, but possibly true.

                For Nietzsche, art is not at all about the communication of truth. Rather, it is about deceit. He claims that art is an escape, a way to combat the world’s hindrance of our will to power. Indeed, art for Nietzsche is a human’s way of asserting its will to live and exerting its purposed on the world. He claims we delight in the deceptions and illusions of art. While he completely differs from Aristotle in these important and central claims, he also agrees with him in certain places. For example, he agrees that art is imitative by nature. But instead of perfectly displaying the world as it is, Nietzsche believes that art does the opposite. He argues that art distorts and deliberately transforms the world. This is again in an illusory fashion, because we need art in order to make life more agreeable. He goes even further to boldly claim that this is a “higher truth” than the everyday truth of the world.

                With Heidegger, my initial claim about a factual truth is more explicitly addressed. Heidegger, in fact, remarks that this true/false idea of the truth of an art work is a diminished concept of truth. He is not concerned with this or that particular instantiation of the truth. In fact he says that particular, factual truths should make us wary of the existence of the truth he thinks we should look for in artwork. He even claims that this understanding of truth is not only problematic for art considerations, but all philosophical considerations, as “truth” should be applicable in all situations, including art and others left by the wayside. He uses the Greek work for truth “alethia” with can be literally interpreted to mean “not concealing”. To interpret truth as “unconcealing”, Heidegger is defining truth as a happening in artworks, not just a property of them. He argues that true is the concealing and revealing cycle in a work. He also notes that this push and pull between concealment and revealing are obscured in everyday life but highlighted in the work of art.

                The readings and discussions in the section opened my eyes to understand the idea of truth in artwork beyond facticity. I was initially caught up in the idea of facts being relayed by art, but I understand and borrow some understanding from each philosopher. I believe can hold universal / non particular truths, and I believe that the structures and plausibility of how those truths are portrayed are relevant to their truthfulness.

Blog 4

I do not think that artworks communicate a truth. Perhaps it is true that they can communicate various truths that people can agree upon, but there is no objective truth in artworks. Plato's account of mimesis lends itself to two different kinds of truth; both of those truths are not the kind that I think artworks communicate. In Aristotle's analysis of Tragedy, I think he points us closer to the point at which artworks can communicate truths. Nietzsche, on the other hand, argues that Tragedy does not in fact lead the audience on a quest towards truth, but rather that it serves as a distraction from the harsh realities of life. I believe that some people may use artwork as a means for distraction, but most people ask questions and pursue knowledge. It is the pursuit of this knowledge that leads spectators towards truths.
Much like Heidegger does in the "Origin of the Work of Art," I think that it is important to search for an understanding of what I mean by truth. While some may still believe in Plato's account of artwork, I do not agree with him. I think that there are two possible understandings of truth from artworks that Aristotle's idea of mimesis permits. On the one hand, there is Plato's sense of truth that sits at the top of his chart of objects. At the top is the idea, form, or truth, below that is the particular or instantiated object of the form, and at the bottom is the imitation of the object. From this perspective, art does contain truth but a lesser version of truth that is twice removed from the actual form of truth.
The other form of truth that I think one can pull from Plato comes out if one does not take his understanding of mimesis as strictly as he does. If one thinks that artworks are simply trying to imitate an image then they have a sense of truth that is relatively straightforward. Artworks contain truth if they accurately represent the object of the painting. This accuracy could come as a simple representation of an image like a painting of a landscape or it could be a painting that has some metaphorical or hidden meaning that may critique some aspect of society. Both of these interpretations do not capture my understanding of either artwork or of truth in artworks, however.
In the Poetics, Aristotle suggests that Tragedy might have some notion of truth, although he does not use that language himself. He claims that Tragedy teaches us the surprising but necessary consequences of our moral actions. Through the process of catharsis we are able to involve ourselves in the Tragedy but hold ourselves at a distance simultaneously. Once we have cleansed ourselves of the emotions attached to the Tragedy we are left with thought. This thought can provide us with some notion of truth. Here again I would like to differentiate from the Platonic sense of truth that I derived earlier. It is not that a Tragedy teaches you something obvious like not to marry your mother and kill your father in the case of Oedipus, but rather that it is supposed to get you to reflect on fate, moral action, and many other such topics. In this reflection it might be possible to find some truths.
Nietzsche takes a rather similar argument to that of Aristotle in his analysis of Tragedy, but he ultimately argues that Tragedy is a way of finding meaning in the absence of truth. For Nietzsche, art does not serve a willed truth because there is no original will to truth. Humans actually want illusion. The desire to know the truth, although not every time, gets in the way of enjoying and living life. Tragedy allows us be deceived and to escape from the harsh realities and truth of life. If Nietzsche's assessment of Tragedy is correct, then there is no truth in artworks. Artwork is just a mere diversion from life and it expresses our vital forces towards the will to power. While this maybe true for some people, I am not sure that it works for everyone. From my own experience, I have found much joy in asking questions in life and learning from those questions, and I am fairly certain that I am not alone.

It is my belief that there are a fair number of people in the world who are interested in finding the truth and are not some crazed individuals who go against the natural order. Of course there are individuals who do enjoy art solely to escape reality, but often those people do not appreciate art properly whether because of educational background or lack of necessary knowledge. If you can read Oedipus and not think about different meanings of fate and moral action, then you either did not understand the Tragedy properly or you somehow acted merely as a spectator. The questions you ask and the answers you give may be different per person, but they will generally fall in the same categories. This is where artworks communicate truth, if at all. While there may be different responses to an artwork, it is likely that if someone were in the same position as you they too would feel the same way as you. They are not the truths of Plato's account of mimesis, but all those different positions represent the possible truths that an artwork might communicate.

Wednesday, October 29, 2014

Response 4

Identifying what we mean by ‘truth’ is crucial to answering the question of whether or not artworks communicate truth. For Aristotle, the best art is a kind that is well constructed. In his discussion of tragedy, he highlights the importance of plot and character—that the events, actions, and thoughts included in the play be ‘realistic’—and coherent with some kind of order in the play. By realistic, I do not mean that plays depict something as mundane and probabilistic as ordinary life; rather, I mean that the goings-on in a play should fit the tone of the work (indeed, one of the challenges of the playwright is to create something that has a tone first and foremost, and secondly to ensure that its tone is consistent). Thus plays, like other forms of art, need to fit within certain rules; they must have a universe of their own, and must make sense within it. Part of that sensibility is moral; thus Oedipus is an appealing character because his decisions make sense to us—he tries to follow the ‘rules’ of being a good person—but his failings are also understandable to us. They do not seem unnaturally contrived, nor do we find ourselves frustrated from engaging with the play by Sophocles artifice. Instead, Sophocles inspires horror and revulsion in us at the same time as he evokes pity; we are able to identify with Oedipus because we are able to apprehend the rules of his universe and how they might be modified to fit our own lives. Yet at the same time that we recognize this truth, we are intended to experience relief, a catharsis: the reality of our lives is (it is to be hoped) far better than that of Oedipus. We recognize the ‘truth’ of his situation—it is understandable within its rules, and it can be understood in terms of principles we derive and recognize from our own lives and experiences—but we also recognize a truth about our own lives: they are not that, but they could be. It is the fact that they are not that is so freeing.
            Nietzsche views art differently. For Nietzsche, art is an escape from truth to terrible for us to grapple with. We want to be alive, he realizes, in a fundamental way that we cannot escape from. But an essential part of being alive is wanting more. Pain and suffering are inevitable; but we live for the joyous moments, holding out hope against whatever mathematical odds, and never quite weighing in the real calculations of how much of our live we spend in pleasure and how much in pain. Art is a distraction; it is a manifestation of our will to truth, to power, but it is a diverting one. It diverts us by channeling out desires and changing the world, so to speak, so that what we desire is no longer inaccessible. In a Nietzschean sense, art is about blending an intelligible order with unbridled feeling and changing our experience of the world—or perhaps more accurately, opening the possibility of different experiences that will satisfy our appetites in illusory yet meaningful ways
            Heidegger’s conception of truth is similar to Nietzsche’s in that it deals with getting closer to ‘truth’ through experience. In Heidegger’s conception, we lose sight of truth when we over-examine an object and take it outside of its original purpose. Equipment thus loses its ‘equipment-ness’ when we begin asking ‘what makes this equipment?’ Yet art gets us to truth, and art asks us to examine something to the precise extent that is required to get a picture (so to speak) of the art. I see this unfolding as follows: when viewing art we do not, at first, ask ‘what makes this art?’ Not if we are approaching it in the right way, at any rate. Instead, we simply experience it. We apprehend it. We consider it, but only in a way of taking in what is there to be offered. That is how we are to interact with art. If an object, like a tool, or a pair of shoes, is represented, then we may consider meaning behind it—truth, if you will. But the truth itself is simply in recognizing those objects for what they are; after that, individual thoughts will differ based on a variety of factors, but so long as they are reasonably relevant (prompted by something that actually has to do with what’s being represented, and not simply being wrong, like calling a pair of shoes an elephant), they are part of the truth of our experience of that object. But we are not examining the object in that case; we are examining the work of art, whose purpose is to be examined. We thus protect ourselves from overstepping the boundaries—our understanding of tools themselves is not broken by our considering what makes them tools. We do not prevent the object from being itself in its fullest sense by being too aware of it. Instead, we examine the artwork, and are aware of what it is, and recognize the object within it. This in turn gives rise to associations. The ‘truth’ of this kind of artwork then is in a movement between concealing and revealing, as dictated by the concept of aletheia. What is concealed is the construction of the art, the real story of the object in the painting, a hyper-awareness of the object. What is revealed is an intuitive understanding of the object and the myriad connections and inferences we have been led by our experience to make about it.

            If art reveals truth—and I think it does—it does so by evoking reasonably well informed responses in the proper mindset. This may consist of apprehending certain rules governing the ‘game’ or ‘craft’ of art—Aristotle, Plato, Gadamer, Dickie, and Kant all deal with this concept—or in getting us to take a certain vantage point from which our thought’s direction is guided. In the latter case, I think of Hume, Kant, Aristotle, and Nietzsche in particular. The shaping of thought—not directly by the artist, but intentionally indirectly through the evocation of personally relevant mental connections, is where the experience of truth comes in relation to art.

Truth: Reflection 4


The question of whether or not artworks communicate truth is a difficult one to answer and depends entirely on how one defines truth. Truth isn’t an easy thing to define though and can be described on so many different levels. I tend to agree with Aristotle when he defines truth or the experience of truth in poetry through the “possible when he talks about tragedies and how they communicate truth. 
Aristotle argues that poetry gives us universal truths over particular truths, and he is particularly interested in the possible. Aristotle states that all truth claims fall into one of 3 categories, either the actual, the possible or the necessary. He argues that the possible is what truth claims about art should be because when something is possible and probable without being necessary, it becomes interesting. I fully agree with this statement. If a work is too plausible, can it really be truth telling or is just something that we already knew and that no artwork had to give us?
Aristotle also focuses on the causal relationship of events in poems. If A then B. But he argues that poetry does this best and communicates the most truth when B seems to be a necessary consequence of A but a surprising one. Afterwards, we feel as if it should have always been that way. Perhaps this is why artworks seem to create truth for Aristotle because if the consequence was likely or guessable, we wouldn’t need the poem at all, we would already have the truth. So artworks communicate truths that we wouldn’t have ever concluded by any other experience.  I think some of the best truths are those that you experience after the truth is revealed to you. It was like it was always floating somewhere under the surface, you just had to experience it or be exposed to the story for it to show itself. I think that art can evoke this kind of truth finding or that “aha” moment when everything is put into better clarity. 
However unlike Aristotle, I don’t really see art as giving us general truths or for art’s purpose to be the communication of truth, rather that we sometimes find truth in art and that it isn’t something found in all artworks and that it isn’t the same for every person who views them. I tend to see art as something that says here I am, use me however you please, and perhaps this is what Nietzsche is getting at when he says art is an escape.  There is a line in a song called “Breathe” that was popular a few years ago that talks about the song writer and the purpose of the song that I think puts this into more perspective. She sings: “And I feel like i’m naked in front of a crowd cause these words are my diary screaming out loud, and I know that you’ll use them however you want to.” This line really speaks volumes to me, and I think is applicable to this question. One can argue that the truth in her song takes shape in the events that are described in the song and that those are the song-writers or singer’s truths that she’s trying to express to her audience. However, she says while this may be my purpose or the truth that i’m trying to get across, I know my audience is going to take my words and what i’m singing about and apply them to whatever is going on in there life or in the way that is going to make them feel the best about themselves, etc. 
Perhaps it’s those words that make me see Nietzsche’s point best over any of the other authors. While I do think that art in some ways points us towards truth or gives us a slice of our own truth, I think the purpose is to be a release or the purpose is to let us find our own kind of truth in a surprising way. Art isn’t trying to shove reality down your throat. It doesn’t ask you to analyze it from every angle in order to find the answers but almost releases you from feeling the need to find the answers or to figure out the world. Can’t there be truth in that release as well? I like that Nietzsche sees art as the attempt to find meaning in the absence of truth, but I want to push his argument further and say that the meaning you find when you disregard truth in the realistic, worldly sense can be a form of truth in itself. We discussed in class how Nietzsche believes that art is a way for us to remake the world to follow our aims in life or to make our lack of aims and misery more palatable. What we really want, in his opinion, is to live not to know everything at the end of the day, and we need art to go on living. He says that art is successful when it recognizes the nature of the obstacles the world shoves at us and overcomes then. It’s not an outlet but it changes the world so that it’s not an obstacle. We have to refigure ourselves and the world so that there is no opposition between us and the world. This refiguring while not based in reality becomes it’s own kind of truth. 
Nietzsche says that we create this new world where Earth and being is no longer an obstacle to us through two impulses either Apollonian or Dionysian. Apollonian truth is based in dreams where we still see a tiny undercurrent of lucidity or when one can fully enjoy the dream but know it’s a dream at the same time. To me, this isn’t truth. This is just covering up reality for the time being. However, I think when art doesn’t have any lucidity and when you are motivated by Dionysian impulses, you fully absorb yourself into something else and completely forgo reality. This kind of experience tears away the veil of illusion and reveals to us a deeper truth of the world. I think that tearing away of the veil can be related to the aha moment in Aristotle’s tragedy. The moment when you see what was possible but highly impossible at the same time, and the thing that surprises you that you always knew was there but that you just needed to be shown. That’s the truth that art shows you in my opinion and the truth it communicates.