Wednesday, September 24, 2014

Reflection 2.2

Based on the evidence put forth by Wollheim, Devereaux, and Kant regarding the nature of artworks, it seems safe to say that beauty is instantiated in a physical object, but it is not a property belonging to the object itself. Rather, beauty is an evaluation on the part of the viewer based on the viewer’s unconscious reaction to the artwork.
            This is clear from the work of Devereaux attempting to critique the study of aesthetics from a feminist perspective. As she notes, the patriarchal “male gaze” is systematically institutionalized from politics to the media, and this widespread and deeply entrenched notion colors our vision of the world almost without notice. What we view when viewing an artwork, then, is not just a pure reception of the physical stimuli there. Rather, the viewer imparts a certain set of expectations to their viewing of the artwork which changes how they interpret what is presented. Devereaux dissects the different levels at which this is present in the film industry, from the creation of male-gendered content to its reception by audiences who have been brought up in a series of cultural norms reinforcing these various aspects of gender. However, if what is important here is the cultural milieu which shapes a viewing of an artwork, then this critique of artworks need not be limited to feminism, but all of the lenses and viewpoints which are brought up just by the way that various linguistic and social communities by which we are always surrounded. Thus, what we perceive in an artwork is colored by how we view it, and not by the object in itself.
            The Kantian critique of beauty follows a similar path. Kant recognizes that judgments concerning the beautiful are not made based on a sort of rational or logical grounds like judgments concerning other qualities of appearances. Rather, the aesthetic judgment is made purely on an intuitive level, and as such, it is totally in the mind of the one perceiving the object. However, what we do in asserting an object is beautiful is claiming that everyone should find that this object affects them in the same way that it affects us. Consensus about the beauty of an object does not make the beauty anymore inherent to it. It only suggests that other viewers are in fact affect in the same way as we are. Coupled with Devereaux’s use of the various lenses that we have in interpreting artworks, this consensus concerning beautiful objects is more probably a common cultural tie than an expression of some quality inherent to the object itself.
The most problematic challenge to this subjective appraisal of beauty comes from Wollheim’s arguments concerning the physical-object hypothesis of an artwork. Wollheim suggests that the artistic quality of an object somehow resides in the instantiation itself, not in the artist’s expression or the viewer’s reception. What is more confounding is that he suggests that there art can be a physical object, though it does not have to be. He appeals to the notion of tokens to try and back that up, such that there is always some physical medium, but that it is not necessarily an object that is the artwork, but rather a more ideal form (ie the difference between a copy of the Iliad and the Iliad as a work of art).

That being said, Wollheim does spend a lot of time explaining the necessity of interpretation, at least when it comes to the performance arts. What makes them artworks, he insists, is their ability to be reiterated and still retain some recognizable “essence” of the piece. Similarly, he quotes Valéry, who says that art has a “new and impenetrable element,” which leads to the “ineliminability of interpretation.” In assenting to this, however, Wollheim opens the door once again for the prospect of a multiplicity of lenses with which a work can be viewed. The fact that art requires interpretation, above and beyond the expressive nature of the art object in and of itself, necessarily means that art requires an interpreter. And, as Devereaux notes, there is no seeing (which we can extrapolate to interpreting) in a vacuum. Thus whatever is viewed in the artwork is evaluated from the standpoint of a particular individual who is plugged into a particular society in a particular way. What presents itself then is a subjective viewing of the artwork, where the beautiful is determined not by the artwork in itself, but by its active perception and interpretation on the part of the spectator.

Saturday, September 20, 2014

Article about Nicki Minaj

Is Minaj's "Feminism" an improvement/evolution from a former era, or is it a total break....is it just refusing to cater to the niceties that other feminisms do? I'm definitely not sure myself. Re-reading the lyrics to Anaconda doesn't have me convinced...

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Bechdel a genius

This article is only tangentially related to our discussion today, but still worth noting. As usual on the internet, read the comments at your own risk.

Tuesday, September 16, 2014

Is beauty a real property of objects?

Is beauty a real property of objects, or is it simply “in the eye of the beholder”?

            As a property, beauty is not one that is inherent in the physical world, but it is rather an evaluation done in the mind. That being said, beauty does require some element of the physical in order to be recognized. Anything can only be properly predicated as beautiful if it is in fact a physical presence. For example, a beautiful sunset requires the actual witnessing of the event; a beautiful painting requires the viewer to be in fact viewing the work in order to understand it; or a beautiful piece of music requires someone to hear the piece in question. However, while beauty requires that there is some sort of physical manifestation, this does not mean that it is an inherent or real property of objects in themselves. Beauty only comes about in the perception of the object, similar to how we perceive colors or textures through the senses. However, beauty requires the added dimension of an intellectual step (or at least a weak one). What is beautiful, while it is generally societally agreed upon, is generally open to a matter of personal taste. Perhaps, what makes beauty this way is the social milieu in which it is debated. We are all told that certain things, like sunsets or tropical beaches, or certain works of art, like Michelangelo’s “David,” are beautiful. Thus, what we perceive as physically pleasing to the senses, whether it be sounds or sights, is tempered by the social understanding, similar to the way that our perceptions of the world are shaped by language. However, because each of us has a unique history of interacting with the world, each person has a varying interpretation of their world. On a wider scale, we can look at differences across cultures. In Burma, the culture of the Kayan Lahwi people holds that women with long necks are beautiful, and so they artificially elongate their necks by adding brass rings around their necks. As we can easily tell, western culture does not have this same sort of standard of beauty. Thus, there is some element of the identification of beauty that does not rest in the physical matter, whether in human bodies, nature, or artwork, but rather in the consciousness of the viewer. And these differences are not limited to cultural differences, can even be seen in differing preferences in individuals. For example, I find that the “Supper’s Ready” suite by Genesis is a beautiful piece of music, with lots of interesting twists and turns and some memorable motifs. However, I know several friends whom I have forced to listen to the track who complained all the way through about what they were listening to and how it was not good (or even listenable). We all listened to the same collection of sounds, and yet I happen to find it pleasing while the others do not. Clearly, there is some element of beauty that goes beyond the physical and is determined in the mind of the perceiver.

The Nature of Beauty -- Short Response

Beauty exists as a phenomenon in the interactive space between an object an observer, but not incidentally. Rather, beauty is a property assigned to objects as the result of culturally-dependent (culturally dependent not merely describe broad categories but sub-cultures as well) schema which is then individuated by external context and mediated by individual taste. An example would help elucidate this.

When I happen across a particularly noteworthy building – meaning one that catches my eye and draws my attention to it – say, in this case, the American Standard Radiator building, I posit that it is beautiful. However, this claim is not something indicative of the building itself, so much as it is truly like any other building and further, is merely a building currently serving as a hotel a particular function which occurs only incidentally as much as it could be serving any other function, which I would be hard-pressed to say gave it any quality of beauty by this particular virtue. However, there is still something to its façade which I describe as beautiful. This is because I hold a culturally-dependent understanding of what is beautiful and what is not, and within that understanding I have individuated myself with a sense of taste which may or may not be unique to me but certainly is not, and need not, be upheld by the entire rest of those members of my cultural set(s). To be clear, I do not mean to say that there is some intersubjective arbiter of the fine details of beauty, but, rather, there is a developmental element which inures us with a conventional sense of what is beautiful and what is not within our own cultural context – which is why art from other cultural contexts can seem so foreign. I speak not merely of Eastern and Western art but divisions in subcultures which additionally have this effect, though perhaps seemingly more subdued. Additionally, this is why we can speak of redefining beauty or claim to find beauty in otherwise non-beautiful objects. When I see the American Standard Radiator Building, I see a building which conforms to a conventional sense of beauty in my Western cultural domain, but my individuated taste see it as not merely this and not merely a building designed in the art deco style, but in addition to all of these, the object, the building, appeals to my taste – I believe it to be a beautiful instantiation of these elements.


This assignment of the property of beauty to this extent seems real to me. However, I must additionally acknowledge that its negation will seem equally real to someone who would assert it – most understandably someone could argue that the building is so excessive as to not be capable of being beautiful. I could argue that they are mistaken, but there is an extent to which we will talk past one another. This is because the nature of beauty is a relativistic one curbed by intersubjective appreciation of objectively defined elements (though often subjectively appreciated) which constitute a culturally-dependent schema under which I operate.

Reflection 2 - short


I believe that beauty is both a real property of objects and can also be subjective to the viewer or thus only beautiful “in the eye of the beholder.” The distinction occurs in the type of object that is being questioned. The main reason I feel this way is because of the natural world and objects that exist naturally that are not a product of human kind. While I cannot prove this, I feel that there are objective standards for beauty. If you see a sunset in nature, it is widely accepted that it is beautiful. Regardless of whether you get a certain feeling from experiencing the sunset or whether you are experiencing the sunset in a certain state or whether you hate the colors in the sunset, it is still considered a beautiful thing that can be recognized as such. 
To better clarify what I am trying to say, take something horrifyingly beautiful in nature for instance like the mirror spider. I absolutely detest spiders. I think they are disgusting, gross and they terrify me; however, I can appreciate to a degree their natural beauty. The mirror spider is beautiful, and I think that could be an objective standard of “beauty.” However, even now as i’m writing this, I see the the flaws in my statement. Two people could come to the same open field and one person could be overcome by beauty and the other could not be affected nor think the scene beautiful at all.  I understand why the phrase beauty is in the eye of the beholder exists. Take people for instance, finding certain people beautiful and others not is an extremely subjective matter; however, can’t a women or a man be by nature beautiful regardless of their personality or character that makes other people see them differently? 
This is a question that really makes me think because unfortunately, I see and understand the argument that beauty is a real characteristic of objects of art or certain things that can be measured and seen and felt across the board, and I also understand that my perception of beauty and others is a subjective matter and is subject to change. I think I would still argue that in a natural instance, a standard of beauty exists. Natural occurrences, mountains, people can be beautiful by nature, but I would also argue that anything man-made is up for interpretation and thus cannot be argued to be without a doubt beautiful. For example, I would argue to my death that Van Gogh’s “Starry Night” is a true example of beauty, yet I know many people who disagree profusely. I feel like something about the fact that humans can think and interpret objects, and that we create art, makes it objective from its’ creation. I could be wrong, but I think that nothing by the hand of humans can be considered an objective truth or objectively beautiful; thus we can’t say anything man-made is beautiful in property while the fact that something exists in nature by some natural, wonderful, mystical Science or magic allows for there to be a small possibility of pure, objective beauty. 

Monday, September 15, 2014

2.1Reflection Paper (S)

Nancun Yu
PR. Kyle Grady
PHIL 330: Aesthetics
15th, Sept. 2014

2.1Reflection Paper (S)
       The question was asked whether Beauty is a real property of objects or it is “in the eye of the beholder”. Albeit both side's arguments have their own truth values. I would hardly be fully convinced by either of them.
In that respect, there are several questions toward believing that Beauty is a real attribute of objects. Foremost of all, if we claim that Beauty as a real property, it seems to obviously declare that Beauty itself is an existed thing. Moreover, if we claim Beauty as real property towards an object, does that mean Beauty it is a physical thing? Furthermore, if it is physically existed, should Beauty be imitable and teachable? On the opposite, if we claim that Beauty is simply “in the eye of the beholder”. Does that mean Beauty itself is an unclear, unlimited quality that people would put on any subject they willing to be described with. Likewise, if Beauty does not have a clear form, how would people be able to discuss it with one another? In addition, if we allow people to think that everybody distinguish their own beliefs on Beauty. Will that bring the future possibility of allowing people distinguish other quality such as moral and ethics?
With previous intention. In my opinion, beauty is supposed to have a clear form as the form of Beauty. There are a few qualities I think the form of Beauty should contain. Foremost of all, the form of Beauty should contain several cleared definition. All the same, in different with other philosophical forms, Beauty as a strain should not be restrained by logic and statements for the intention of lifting a space allows the artist to express emotions freely. Furthermore, the form of Beauty should not be counted as “property” of any objects, even know many objects might share the “property” from the form of Beauty. The Beauty itself should be instituted as a form which can be abstract out from actual studies and it does not need to be really physically existed.

As much as the first claim, there are also truth values in the second claim. Personally, I prefer the second statement. Still, there are few details I would like to debate. Granted, everybody view artworks based on different judgments. However, in a previous discussion we had admitted that there is an essential function of artworks – to affect people on their emotions. It might create an illusion that beauty is behold under the viewer. But by viewing artworks, the viewer has learned the form of Beauty instead of practice their own beliefs on beautiful. The process of viewing allows the viewer to be more consciously involved with the discovery about the form of Beauty but they did not create or “hold” the form of Beauty “in” them.